Don’t let the Hamilton clues throw you!
We’ve guessedJellyfish,Seahorse,Whatchamacallit, and more correctly.
We bet $1 trillion that Sun isLeAnn Rimes.

Credit: Michael Becker/FOX
But from the beginning of season 4, one contestant has confounded EW’sMasked Singersleuths: Mushroom.
Some fans think he’sWork ItstarJordan Fisher, while others are convinced singer and dancerTodrick Hallhasto be under the mask.
Let’s get something out of the way first theHamiltonclues.

Al Pereira/Getty Images
Like with Serpent, Mushroom’s clue packages contained numerous references to Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hit musical (e.g.
Moving on, let’s talk about other major clues favoring Blacc.
Well, Blacc briefly worked in the corporate world for Ernst & Young before his career took off.
As far as we can tell, both Fisher and Hall have used their real names throughout their careers.
Now, let’s introduce the supporting cast of clues, if you will.
Then, we saw two black beetles.
The numbers add up for Blacc too.
Before the season began,the show teasedthat there were 46 Grammy nominations between all the celebrities.
There are 45 among contestants already revealed and EW’s guesses Rimes andNick CarterasCrocodile.
Blacc was nominated in 2015, while neither Fisher nor Hall have nominations.
Last but not least, there’s the question of Mushroom’s ever-changing voice.
Just listen to a few of Blacc’s songs below to hear him flex his own versatility.
Tell us that’s not Mushroom!