“We were always looking for off-the-wall ideas,” says co-showrunner Robert Singer.

There are two cuts in particular that Singer remembers fondly.

There were things like that that were just great."

SUPERNATURAL

Sergei Bachlakov/The CW

“Jensen felt kind of silly.

He was like, ‘Really I gotta do this?’

“And when Todd did his monologue at the end, you really felt for the guy.”

SUPERNATURAL

Sergei Bachlakov/The CW

Eleven seasons later, “Monster Movie” remains a favorite in the fandom, and Singer agrees.

“Our wild swings always seem to work out well one way or another,” says Singer.

“That one just clicked.