Check out our rankings, then cast a vote for the singer that’s No.

  1. Jessica BrownProducers chose to highlight her one-time battle with meth addiction, butDr.

NEXT PAGE: Nos.

American Idol

  1. Brooke WhiteCall her Nanny McPlease!

Her Corrine Bailey Rae number was a four-note snoozer!

But what show are we watching when Simon gives Golden Tickets to undeniably middling vocalists?

But her version of Whitney Houstons overdone Run to You was a hot mess.

Judges, clean thy ears!

NEXT PAGE: Vote for your favorite singer

American Idol Poll

Flashback!

Sanjaya were all on ourAmerican IdolPower List