''American Idol'' recap: Catching us by surprise
What if hes got a point? I thought to myself. Well, hold on to your Orvis catalogs. Tonights hour proved thatIdolhas some worms left in its bait can. (Sorry, this fishing metaphor has me hooked through the gills.) Take, for example, Carly Smithson, the tattooed Irish songbird who closed tonights show. Anyhow, knowing all this, I approached Carlys audition with skepticism. Didnt she already get her shot at the Big Show?...